There Is No Learning In AI Doing Students’ Work: IIT Kharagpur Professor

Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kharagpur Professor Plaban Kumar Bhowmick, from the Department of Artificial Intelligence and principal investigator of the National Digital Library of India, has highlighted a crucial distinction between cognitive offloading and cognitive scaffolding in the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in education.

Explaining the difference between the two concepts, Professor Bhowmick said educators use cognitive scaffolding to create a supportive structure that enables students to learn independently.

“We do something that we call cognitive scaffolding, where we put up a structure within which the student feels supported. Now, AI can take a problem given by a student and solve it on the student’s behalf. So, the question is whether AI in this form is actually helping the student. In my view, it is not really helping because this is what we call cognitive offloading or cognitive hijacking. Basically, there is no learning happening in this scenario,” he said.

“The AI is doing the job for the student, and the learning goal is not really achieved. But if we think of AI as a form of cognitive scaffolding, the student does the entire job while the AI provides support. That is where the Fermi AI Tutor comes in. It supports students in problem-solving while they work through the problems on their own. The AI tutor supports the student, but does not solve the problem for them,” he added.

Asked whether any aspect of the Fermi AI Tutor had genuinely surprised him, Professor Bhowmick pointed to its underlying design philosophy. He said the platform could change how students perceive and use AI, moving beyond the idea of AI as a tool that users simply pick up and put down.

ALSO READ: AI Helps Homework, But Hurts Test Scores: Study

AIFermi AI TutorIIT KharagpurNational Digital Library of IndiaProfessor Plaban Kumar Bhowmick
Comments (0)
Add Comment